Digital Justice

“Come on, it won't hurt you, Charles.”

I hesitated, thirty four and still uncorrupted, but facing a daunting challenge, peer pressure with a soon to be legalized substance. I glanced away from the object, and into my brother Derrick's earnest face. My trepidation evident, he sighed, and began to withdraw the offer but I seized it from his receding hand.

With a single movement, I inhaled intoxication, swirling, warm, and smoky into my lungs, savoring it, eyes closed in attempt to immerse myself, body and soul in the experience.

I felt no tremor under my feet, no alteration in my position, but suddenly, something in my internal composition shifted, while a sightless reflection on my external surroundings admitted an uncertainty. The wide southern facing windows, filled by the early morning sun, suddenly ceased to admit their warm light, replaced by a cooler electric illumination. A disorientation, akin to vertigo, infected my being, and I felt as if I was being stretched, pulled by an inexorable force through a narrow tube.

With a final thrust of force my eyes were forced open. Instead of a finished basement furnished with comfortable second hand couches, a smallish flat screen TV on the wall, and an ancient but serviceable Xbox 360, I resided in a cushy office chair positioned in the middle of a nondescript room lit by a dim overhead florescent. Two official looking persons, one male and the other female, had been substituted for the well known friends and family. These two dour individuals flanked my chair with an expression of bureaucratic boredom, the facial exhibition of one performing a common task in their occupation.

“Clayton,” said the woman after a moment, “after undergoing The Cave Citizen Test, you have been awarded a Tier Three citizenship.”

“Clayton, Please sign here, to confirm your status,” said the man, handing me a clipboard and pointing unnecessarily at the line marked with an X.

“Huh, what?” I replied. “Who are you, and what am I doing here?” gesturing toward the sparse, walls.

My interrogators looked at each other and sighed.

“It's your turn,” the man said to the woman.

“Me?”

“You know I did the last one.”

“Clayton, what do you remember?” she said to me.

“Why do you keep calling me Clayton. My name's Charles.”

“No it isn't Clayton. All men are named Charles in the Cave. But we repeat your real name to reassert your sense of reality. You've been immersed in a extremely lifelike simulation for over a week.”

I tried to stand in protest, but wobbled on weak knees. The man steadied my situation, and returned me to the seat.

“You're exhausted by the procedure, but don't worry,” he said, “you'll have normal functionality soon enough, but while you're recovering please sign here, so we can escort you to a Recovery Room.”

I pushed the papers away as two sets of memories jostled for space in my brain. Two mothers, two fathers, two childhoods, two identities framed on two different faces.

“Please,” he said.

“Explain the test to me,” I said to earn myself some more time for reflection.

“We did before you began it,” she said, “You and your parents signed the appropriate documents. Everything's been done in accordance with the law. If anyone can explain the procedure, you can as you recently experienced it. You still retain the memories.”

The man fiddled with his clipboard, and I grasped at it now, as if were capable of explaining this horrid dream. On it was a single white sheet, which said,

The citizen has been awarded (check box):

First Tier Citizenship
Second Tier Citizenship
Third Tier Citizenship
Fourth Tier Citizenship

Sign here X

“That's it?” I said without expecting a suitable reply, so I wasn't devastated by her reply.

“Further documentation will be provided in the Recovery Room.”

“I won't sign it until I understand my situation,” and because I knew my mobility was helpless, I gazed fiercely around the room as if it might release a secret.

“I'm sorry, I am not permitted to dispense further information,” she said.

“At this moment I can't remember who my real mother is, and you expect me to make this decision?”

“There is no decision. You've already made every choice capable of impacting your future.”

“It was so real!”

“It has to be, to provide a recommendation worthy of determining a citizens tier of citizenship, but the memories will fade entirely. Within a year, the entire experience will be erased. Now, can we move along. Some of us have other work to do today.”

“You aren't struck by the injustice you're an accessory to. The system has labeled me inferior forever over a solitary error.. How can I be judged for the rest of my life by an action I can't recollect?”

“Citizen, I didn't invent the system, nor do I have the authority to alter it. We are both second tier citizens, considered capable of fulfilling the law, but not enacting it.”

“And I?”

“Are capable only of obeying it, and will be obliged to do by pervasive surveillance.”

“For one mistake.”

“For failing to love virtue with your heart and soul.”

“What does that even mean! How can I be judged for a digital experience, yet indistinguishable while immersed, yet whose events will recede, leaving me unable to reflect on my error?”

“A real illusion, the digital shadows of reality reflected on your brain. Don't you still remember the delight of the sun on your face?”

“My first kiss...”

“The joy of a swim in the ocean?”

“And my friends, nothing but digital compositions.”

I fell silent considering my options, watching their reactions and observing my own steadily augmenting anger. My life, which still mostly escaped my remembrance, was over. And the life which still burned in my brain, with its lifeless family and its lies, existed immaterially.

“You needn't agonize over this event,” she said as if she could read my mind, “A lot of the people in your life are third class citizens. They live perfectly normal lives and contribute to society through their economic activity. Almost half of all citizens are labeled third tier.”

“The injustice...” and I desperately flailed about, as helpless in my attempts to elucidate my position, as I was to cross the room.

They only stood silently, immovable. Into the stillness I said.

“Is there no hope of redemption?”

And my reply was the tranquility of the just.

Recent:

Relevant:

Comments