What is Worth Remembering?

As I cross the threshold I reread the motto spanning the archway, “The Unexamined Life is Not Worth Living.” and enter that accursed auditorium. How this perfectly wise saying became such a perversion is an arduous tale which I feel incapable of relating at this moment. But my steps slow as I walk down the aisle to my designated seat. There it is, the cheap fabric with a label, Sophie Diotima, marking the location for my monthly checkup.

I recline and observe the arrival of the others. Each sits in the same position they've used a couple hundred times before, except for those who have been replaced. There are always new participants in our assembly. It would be wrong to call this...

“Hello Sophie,” says Phillip Proust, as he sits into the chair next to mine. “Glad to see you haven't been replaced yet.”

I forgive him his discourtesy, no one speaks of another's... , but it is difficult for Phillip to maintain a proper decorum. He is so full of life, one begins to believe there are stainless, fully functioning people, as the m-physicians tell us. I am not one of them, but as...

“They say I am to see a new m-physician today,” said Phillip, and I reach out gently and squeeze his arm, because I can sense his anxiety. One's future rests entirely on their meta's verdict.

“Of course, my Recaller (I note Phillip's use of the more informal term) was old, not unstable. You can't remain or even become a m-physician if you suffer from insecurity,” and I realize how much I misjudged Phil's conduct.

“Then you're sure to be one,” I say smiling, but he frowns at the compliment and turns aside for a moment, apparently afflicted by self doubt.

I've sufficiently demonstrated why no one ever considered me for a m-physician.

My other neighbor, I'm seat 7G, sits down, and I realize the other ninety-nine seats are occupied. Without a spoken word, and there are children scattered among the assembly, we focus on the screen sinking from the ceiling.

No participant can explain exactly what occurs when the show starts. The mind can't consciously process the devices used by the m-physicians to prep patients for the formal check up. But it feels like one's mind is being scooped out of their body, and placed before an omniscient presence. The past month's memories are unspooled like a film, which causes a stretching sensation, and cleaned of impurities, like clarified butter. With that process concluded, a second begins. The impression of being observed redoubles. Imagine a bug beneath a magnifying glass, a giant eye peering down from above, with the poor insect uncertain if the inspection will end in an abeyance, a box, or a bright burning light. I can't tell if the lights of the auditorium dim, or one's focus is overwhelmed so completely that observing any extraneous articles becomes impossible.

Sinking back into consciousness is like trudging through mud after walking on air. But there is a certain clarity, like after cleaning one's glasses when they are covered in grime. I look left at 7H, Maria, and smile. I repeat the movement to my right, and Phillip returns the compliment, our past trouble forgotten.

It's easy to remain seated for the next hour as 7A, B, C, D, E, and F are called for their personal rememberance. A certain feeling suffuses one's brain, and it spreads, semi-paralyzing, into the limbs, resembling a calming pain. I nod repeatedly, turning sometimes to Phillip and Maria, looking like a pair bobbing our heads to music. There is no talking. Just the silent sound of motion in the auditorium.

At last, so long, so short, Phillip is gone. Where did he go? And someone is taking me by the hand and leading me down the aisle. On the walk to the m-physician's office my mind sloughs off its lethargy, and I almost decide to engage in conversation with the attendant leading me by the hand, but I remain docile, as every patient knows that's how they prefer us.

At end of the hallway the attendant opens the door to a room and I step inside as he closes it from the outside. Sitting in a chair beside another chair is a man I know only as Berkeley. All the m-physicians choose a suitable name, but I'm not sure if his isn't meant ironically. He motions me to the chair, and draws forth his tools. They remind me of those used by eye doctors to examine the cornea, iris, lens, and retina, while also checking for cancer. Someone once said, the eyes are the windows to the soul, and whether it is true or not, the Recallers believe it. Berkeley pushes the device towards me, and I rest my chin on a bar while he shines a bright light into my eyes. Normally this elicits excruciating pain, like a lumbar puncture of the brain, as the memories of the last month are brought to the fore for a second cleaning, a secondary review. Throughout the procedure the m-physician asks questions related to their viewing. They fit into two categories. “Do you remember this detail? What time did you leave the house yesterday? Or, what exactly did your friend Winston say in regards to the Government's decision to censure the new satirical TV show?” Questions relating to recall. Answering these questions further focuses the memory of the patient, and presumably the Recaller. Other questions require the patient to explain the relevance of emotions and thoughts too ephemeral for the m-physician to understand without assistance. Questions like, “Why did you do this? How did you feel when Francine interrupted you at work? Or, what was your reasoning for choosing to read that book which you specifically needed a note of approval to access?” The victim to coerced to divulge their secrets to the authorities.

Eventually the examination turns to the most distressing question: “How are you coping with that troublesome memory from five years ago?” M-Physicians focus their tool on that memory and draw it forth. Time makes the mind weary, and turns memories to tissue paper, but the sadistic spy twists and manipulates until it seems like a tooth is coming out, instead of a recollection. Under examination the memory becomes as clear as the day it occurred, and one is forced to face their shame afresh.

But today isn't any normal day. I had suffered enough from that memory. I didn't dare allow them to remind me of it. The exact curve of the object, the softness of the touch, or the odd blue hue it exhibited. I had decided to resist, and now I must admit I lied to you dear reader. I felt neither of the effects of the screen in the auditorium, but mimicked the behavior expected of one felled by its power. One can devise a particular goggle like object to filter its effects.

I pushed hard against the observational implements and trapped Berkeley against the wall, or as he would have said, between two ideas existing only in the mind of the perceiver. My plan wasn't well conceived. Avoiding the appointment was impossible. Required monthly by the government, any who fail to attend are deemed to be too untrustworthy, or too unstable and therefore unproductive. I thought to threaten and cajole Berkeley into some relief for my condition. But my time was limited, as a normal review only takes ten minutes.

We spoke in fierce whispers for five minutes. I demanded that he leave my memory alone.

Doesn't everyone have a right to the regulation of their own mind?” I asked.

A mind must be properly maintained like a good watch,” Berkeley replied.

Aren't some memories worth forgetting? Isn't it bad enough that I must forever retain the shreds of my shame, without your relentless inspection?” I pleaded.

The unexamined life is not worth living,” he reiterated.

His persistent, unwavering belief shattered my feeble arguments. His answers didn't engage with my questions but hammered at my illogical defenses until I could resist no more. At last he looked at me, with the hint of a frown. I thought I saw real regret upon his features.

Do you really wish to forget?” he asked.

I only wish to not remember,” I said, knowing if he did not offer mercy I no hope remained.

Everyone is a single granted reprieve if their life requires it. I will erase the memory.” Berkeley paused. “But there is one condition.”

Anything.” I breathed.

You must offer an account of your actions today, in a journal.”

And he offered me the paper that you see before you. Then he handed me a purple liquid which he drew out of a cabinet. Not knowing if it would bring the relief I sought, or lead toward my replacement, I drank it, knowing that further resistance in the face of mercy, true or feigned, was fruitless. He said, “Go home and rest. In the morning the effect will be complete, and the memory will be erased. But leave the journal.”


Meta-Physician Berkeley's notes

For many years Patient Sophie Diotima has experienced significant difficult with a memory from her teenage years. The memory has continually disrupted her life as a trustworthy, productive member of society. She has been allocated her single reprieve.

While she believes the medicine will erase her memory, which she holds to be shameful, it will not. It will erase the memory of her rebellion today. Whether she can bear the continual renewal of a memory she detests is another question. She must bear it, as we all must, until either she is found unfit for service, or she can move on, either by accepting it as part of herself or rejecting it completely as unrelated to her current self. As her Meta-Physician, I will continue my work to aid her overcome her burden.

Recent:

Relevant:

Comments