The Other Person's Choice

“I need to explain why I chose him, instead of you.”

“Father, I'd rather spend this time speaking of anything else.”

The father leans back into the rigid plastic, and points. “Look how they hurry.”

“This is a place where haste can make a difference.”

“In a minority of cases, sure, but most outcomes are a long time in the making.”

He turns his head to the left, observing his father in profile, “Like mine.”

“I didn't mean that.”

“After you started talking, you realized it was where the thought was developing.”

“It's not you're fault. It's mine.”

“I don't want to talk about that part.”

“I just want you to know...”

A siren blares and the father leaps from his chair. He turns awkwardly on the spot, searching for the source of the interruption, as if it means the end of the world to him.

“Please sit down, you're making a fool of yourself,” says the man, and he almost rises from his seat to re-seat the other, but can't muster the energy.

A few people rush by, and the man peers eagerly after them, as if he can glean some precious secret that will alter his family's fate. When the commotion subsides he sits, and tries to recapture his thoughts.

“I love you as much as your...”

“We say, I love you, like it's a talisman offering protection...”

“And if I had known, I would have acted differently...”

“But there is no aegis to hide behind, no shelter against the impending storm...”

“I would have...

“Except you discovered one, but you...”

“Inoculated another.” they finish together.

After a moment of silence, one man says to the other. “It was a strange, unexpected gift.”

“I think they should slow down,” says the father looking up at the long fluorescent light bulbs embedded in the ceiling. “If someone caused an accident, or only hurt themselves, the operation of the machine would lose part of its critical function, like if person loses the function of their liver.”

“And at this point, the timing is most inconsequential.”

“But the time we make out choices at is critical. On that particular day, I believed you were brave, that he was fragile. On any other day, a year later, my opinion and choice would have been altered.”

“Dad...” says the man, pleading in his eyes.

“Even a second could have changed my choice. Such a miraculous, hurried selection. It seemed like a dream, an if I hesitated... and who can be blamed, when offered the option to alleviate the suffering of one, who would dare not to choose?”

The man, observing, his sadness withdrawing, and hands firmly grasping the edges of his synthetic seat, begins to vibrate, as his face works through a series of fierce contortions. At last he thrusts himself upward like a volcanic burst, and stares so vibrantly at the older man's hunched, squirming figure, that the father ceases and slowly meets the confronting gaze.

“If you don't cease your story, you'll never see me again,” he says through clenched teeth, hesitant to yell surrounded by strangers doing their duty.

“Ah,” the father returns ruefully, “the worst curse a parent can contemplate.”

A second, extended silence follows this rebuttal, and it stretches until the two companions recognized a change in time, as the light beyond the curtains dims, relative to the light inside.

“I heard once,” begins the man, “a story about Emily Dickinson.”

The other shifts, attempting to awaken legs which sleep, and massaging shoulders which ache from stiffness.

“Critics used to think her seclusion was a result of a shyness. Now they believe the seclusion was itself the cause, not an effect of something else. My theory, she secluded herself, and barely published, because she began to believe; what was the purpose of interacting with corpses?”

The other fails to reply, and the man prods.

“I have no evidence for my hypothesis, except, she rarely published (and only early in her life), she didn't often see others, and the themes of her extended poetic collection.”

When no answer is forthcoming, he continues, “Well, what do you think?”

“I thought you didn't want to talk about it!”

“You're intentionally misunderstanding. I didn't want to discuss you're fabled choice. But my fate, I'm willing to contemplate.”

“Are you terrified?”

“I'm...” he begins, but restrains his speech, as a nurse and two patients pass. One walks with a shuffling gait, while the other clasps an IV stand, leaning on it as if on a cane.

“I'm sorry,” the father says.

“You shouldn't be, replies the man, wiping his eyes repeatedly and shivering. “There's only one possible outcome for everyone. And don't speak of your choice. I can't bear your guilt anymore.”

The father clutches the man, sharing a mutual saturation.

“But regardless of my choice, that's what a parent experiences. Whether the popular phrase is; no parent should have to watch their child die, no mother should have to bury a son, or no parent should have to bury their child, this phrase expresses the guilt of awakening a being capable of realizing the devastating horror of its infinitesimal temporary existence. Every parent desires to die before their children, to escape liability. It has little to do with the suffering of the child, because everyone knows the child must eventually grow old and suffer. It reveals the parent's desire to evade responsibility.”

Clasping, the father continued speaking, when he realizes the other man can not.

“It is such a horrid idea, such a barbaric concept, and yet I remember a scene from TV, I can't remember which, where a father declares his gratefulness for the premature and painless, accidental death of his daughter. She was not cognizant of her doom, she did not suffer, and most crucially of all, she did not yet have the ability to comprehend death. To live and to die, without understanding either, or preparing for the latter.”

Then the father falls quiet, for he knows not what to say, what might hurt, or help, or harm, and silence becomes easier than speech.

At last the son, exhausted of tears speaks.

“I do not wish to cry...”

“It is alright to weep.”

“I cry for myself, and I cry for succor, in the full knowledge, that no one can offer it to me. It is like I am seeking to project my sorrow, in search of help, but there is no one capable of lending it, no one outside the box of reality, there is no doorway, no one who may enter and aid me.”

“I wish...”

“Life begins in a ditch, and it ends in one, a muddy, worm filled hole in the ground, where we persist in a second life which is shorter than the first!”

The clock strikes ten, and the last stragglers of the day, those visiting patients in recovery, begin to leave, and as they leave they witness two men clutching each other, and hear the faint, strangled, sobbing repetition.

My poor boy,
My poor boy,
My poor boy,

Recent:

Relevant:

Comments