Fish, A Phone, or Paradise

Neil carelessly tossed a smartphone towards Stephen, who dove into the sand to catch it.

“You could have broken it,” he said, in order to explain the scrapes he had earned.

Neil shrugged. “It's already broken.” He took the device back and examined the black screen, as if he needed to confirm the truth of the statement for himself.

“We can repair it. Unless you smash it.”

“I don't know,” Neil said, “but I'd rather have a working air conditioner.”

Neil turned from the shore toward the offices and docks, dropping the device into the sand. He was looking for any semblance of activity. Stephen carefully, stealthily scooped the phone and placed it into a pocket of his torn jeans. He looked where Neil looked. There was no one.

“At least we have your fishing equipment,” Stephen said finally. “I've even become quite proficient this past year.”

“Right,” Neil said, rolling his eyes. “If it wasn't for me, you'd have starved to death by now.”

They became silent, avoiding each others eyes as they contemplated Neil's words. When did such a casual joke become deadly serious? In quiet reflection they watched the crash of the waves, and fished for their supper.


“Do you see that?”

Far down the darkened beach, a collection of lights shone.

“Oh, thank god,” said Stephen, “Some electrical equipment still functions!”

He climbed out of his sleeping bag, and began to move toward the lights, but Neil placed a hand on his shoulder.

“Hold on, they'll be here soon enough, and we need to hide the fishing equipment. It's all that's keeping the skin on our bones. And I don't think that's electrical lighting.”

Five minutes later they could see that the source of the light was flame, and after an equal interval of time they could make out a crowd of people holding torches.

“Should we run?” said Stephen, already with their meager possessions in a small sled, and hand grasping the draw cord.

“I thought you wanted to meet them?”

“When I thought they were civilized. Didn't you want to hide?”

“You've convinced me otherwise. I'm a trusting individual. After all I rescued a unknown person from starvation by teaching them to fish. But let's hide the gear.”


Neil had expected the torchbearers to be their first guests, but suddenly out of the darkness a woman and man approached them. It was dark enough that the man tripped over the sled, and the woman helped him to his feet. Neil saw her eyes darting everywhere, but the man only frowned at the ground.

“We were going to meet the light,” said the woman, “We didn't see you.”

“The light is coming this way. Why not wait with us?” said Neil.

The woman assented, and Neil took a moment to examine the man's face. Though he seemed tall, he stood with body scrunched together, as if to avoid a blow or carrying a great weight. Stephen tried to draw them into conversation, but the woman replied distractedly and the man refused to speak.

Just then the crowd passed the darkened lighthouse, and Neil could hear one voice raised and exhorting the crowd. He listened carefully, hoping to recognize the voice of a friend, but the land breeze swept both word and tone out to sea. The edge of light crept forward, forming a perceptible bubble, yet those on the outside were still surprised when they found themselves surrounded by seventy flames.

“Sinners,” a harsh, languid voice spoke its opinion of them.

They saw the speaker as the nuclei of the light moved to meet them. Neil noticed that he was five foot seven, wearing a t-shirt and hiking pants, but with a deformity of the mouth that caused his speech to be both garbled and rasping.

“Join John, for I lead the humble to paradise, if only you will repent.” The four targets of his speech had to lean forward to decipher the words from the noise that the voice made.

“I'm not sure what we have to repent of,” said Neil.

“Of the love of technology that draws us away from the reality of living, and turns our eyes away from the face of God.”

“And where is the paradise that you are leading these people to?”

John appeared distracted for he did not answer, but a follower who stood nearby said, “To the land of milk and honey, 'Frisco.”

Neil opened his mouth to reply, but John pounced upon Stephen, shrieking, “What foulness do you carry!”

The bubble of light condensed as the crowd moved to watch, as the two men wrestled in the sand. Stephen had been fingering the phone in his pocket, and now he clutched it like it was his only child, as John scrabbled and scratched at the defending hands.

In triumph the prophet stood with the phone raised, and as his followers cheered he dashed it upon a rock. While Stephen collected the broken pieces and wept, John said “Let the vile be destroyed, for it was this that brought the act of God upon us.”

“Hey! Who do you think you are, that you can act so crazy” said Neil.

John looked at him with the fire glinting off his eyes. “Our greatest error was assuming that we were sane to begin with.”

Neil clenched and unclenched his fists, unsure whether to act.

“Hey I know you!” someone said, grabbing the silent man and trying to draw him closer into the light. The speaker fell to the ground, knocked down by a blow from the woman, but all eyes had been drawn to the pair.

“It's the president,” a voice said, and the rest took up the words, so that it rolled back and forth, competing the waves. This time, as John grappled the president, his followers blocked the woman from intervening.

“It's a reckoning,” said John. “God acted to prevent a terrible evil, and it is upon you that the evil falls. You and others like you.”

“God didn't do anything,” said Thomas, the ex-president, “The sun released a massive solar flare. The news announced it minutes before it reached earth. You must have seen the story.”

He looked around for confirmation, and Neil nodded.

“There is no guilt on my head, for a solar flare.” Thomas said.

Then John's frothing, misshapen face, transformed and for the first time he seemed lucid.

“I had a dream that night,” he began, “and I saw humanity, great and terrible, devouring the earth and each other. Worse, I saw the hour of mankind approaching, for the appeal of abominable weapons was too much to be resisted by those who hold them. Framed in light, God waited for the moment, and it came. As desire and hate grew, the knowledge to love your brother as yourself failed, and men in high castles began a process by which fire would engulf the world. I saw the tears of God, shining like the torches in the night. I saw him cry light into the darkness. For though he loved the liberty he gave to us, he loved our joy more. And the agony that he suffered to condemn to death so many, that he might rescue a remnant, was immeasurable. To sacrifice many that a few might carry on. He prevented a nuclear war.”

“You're saying that God caused the solar flare,” said Neil.

“I am.”

“That's crazy.”

“What did I already say about insanity?"

Neil observed a subtle change in John's speech as the topic changed.

“We won't follow you,” Neil said, pointing at himself and Stephen. “We are content here.”

Thomas and the woman also declined, and some of the crowd made to abuse them, but John said.

“Let the sinners wallow and not follow. Let them decry their sins or let them lie. We leave them to God.”

The light moved on as the four sat watching, and listening to the waves.

Neil said, “We're better than John claimed. The world has changed, but it hasn't ended. Humanity will continue on as it always has; loving, suffering, believing, and searching. No better or worse than before.”

Then he noticed that Thomas was weeping and he said to him.

“What is wrong, sir?”

With hunched shoulders and tears falling, gleaming with the pale moon light, Thomas said,

“It wasn't in the news yet. They had just began to bombard the city, and the armor was soon to follow. They had their finger hovering over the trigger, as did I. Then the solar flare hit. Had I already pressed the button? Am I guilty or was I saved?”

Neil and Stephen stood with eyes wide open, drinking in the light in the dark.

And the sea lapped ceaselessly at the shore.

Comments